Less Soreness Does Not Necessarily Mean Less Inflammation
Cold-water immersion is one of the better-supported recovery strategies for reducing delayed onset muscle soreness.
A recent 2026 meta-analysis of 52 studies found reductions in soreness, creatine kinase, and myoglobin after cold water immersion.
But creatine kinase and myoglobin mainly reflect muscle damage, not inflammation itself.
Cold also affects pain signaling, which can make muscles feel better even if the underlying inflammatory response has not changed much.
This is the key distinction:
Feeling less sore is evidence of improved perceived recovery not proof that inflammation has been switched off.
What Happens to Inflammatory Markers?
Direct evidence is mixed.
In one important study, participants performed strenuous resistance exercise and then completed either cold water immersion or active recovery.
Muscle biopsies collected over the next 48 hours showed increases in inflammatory cells and cytokines after exercise, but those responses were not significantly lower with cold-water immersion.
Another meta-analysis found no meaningful effect of cold-water immersion on CRP or IL-6 during recovery.
The 2025 systematic review of cold-water immersion and health outcomes reported something even more interesting: pooled inflammatory measures increased immediately and one hour after cold exposure.
That does not mean cold plunges are necessarily inflammatory or harmful.
The studies were small and heterogeneous, and several involved exercise or other physiological stressors.
But the results clearly argue against the simplistic claim that cold exposure reliably “reduces inflammation.”
Recovery Benefits Can Come With a Training Trade-Off
Cold water immersion may still be useful when rapid recovery matters.
Athletes competing again soon after a difficult event may value reduced soreness more than maximizing every long-term training adaptation.
Resistance training is different.
Some inflammatory and cellular stress signals after lifting are part of the process that stimulates muscle remodeling.
A long term training study found smaller gains in muscle mass and strength when cold water immersion was repeatedly used immediately after resistance exercise compared with active recovery.
A 2024 meta-analysis similarly concluded that regular post-workout cold-water immersion may modestly reduce muscle hypertrophy, although the evidence quality remains limited.
This does not mean an occasional cold plunge destroys muscle growth.
It means that using one immediately after every strength session may be unnecessary if maximizing hypertrophy is the primary goal.